Pakistan’s Dual Messaging To Iran And Saudi Amid Escalating Houthi Attacks

Pakistan's Dual Messaging To Iran And Saudi Amid Escalating Houthi Attacks

On September 10, Pakistan’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Sajjad Haider Khan was asked how Islamabad would honour its obligations under the Mecca pact after the Houthi barrage on Saudi Arabia escalated.

There was “no such thing under discussion right now,” he said, adding that Pakistan would act under the agreement when the time came.

The same day, Field Marshal Asim Munir met Saudi Defence Minister Prince Khalid bin Salman in Riyadh at a gathering of Mecca pact allies’ defence chiefs on intelligence cooperation, military coordination and capability integration. He stressed that this was brainstorming between two foreign ministers, not a written offer. Three days later, ministers of Pakistan, Turkey and Saudi Arabia met in Riyadh and agreed to deploy forces. It was the most operational public statement any Pakistani minister had made since the August signing, and it fits the distinction drawn by Tehran-based analyst Javad Heiran-Nia, who noted that Iran tolerates the defence of Saudi territory but treats offensive action against the Houthis as a red line. Iran’s response came in two registers. After the activation, state media took a sharper tone, and the Tasnim news agency ran a headline accusing Turkey and Pakistan of joining the Saudi war. Whether a reconnaissance role would satisfy Tehran is unclear. Asif did not specify whether it takes place over Saudi territory, along the Yemeni border, or through intelligence passed to Saudi-led forces. The joint statement gave no troop numbers or equipment lists. This stance is not new. Pakistan has run on two tracks since the spring.

On September 25, Pakistan’s Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif told the UN General Assembly that any threat to Mecca and Medina was a red line. On 2 October, Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar described the Tehran side of the conversation in unusual detail. First, Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baghaei on October 4 said that Tehran hoped the deployment reports were untrue. On March 3, Dar told the Senate that he had reminded Araghchi of Pakistan’s defence obligations to Saudi Arabia and that the Iranian foreign minister had asked for assurances that Saudi territory would not be used against Iran.

He said he raised the pact with President Masoud Pezeshkian and Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi on the margins of the UN meetings in New York and briefed them on how Pakistan would honour it. Iran, he said, had floated a political approach to the Houthis as an alternative to military action. Pakistan’s Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said afterwards that Islamabad and Ankara were present in the operational area in a supportive role, that Pakistan was involved in reconnaissance, and that only Saudi forces were fighting.