Arnold Dix, an Australian tunnel rescue expert renowned for his role in the successful 2023 rescue of 41 workers from the Silkyara tunnel in India, has assessed the situation at Nepal’s Chilime hydropower project. He stated that individuals caught in the initial surge of water, mud, and debris faced ‘no possibility of survival.’ This tragic incident underscores the dangers associated with hydropower projects in flood-prone regions.
He described the disaster as one of the most extreme natural events he has encountered in decades of working on underground emergencies. “In all my decades of work with underground emergencies and natural disasters, I have never encountered an event combining this scale, this violence and this complexity.
Dix, who has joined the emergency search operation at the flood-hit Chilime tunnel, shared a video from the site on X and said the scale and force of the disaster meant there was no basis for blaming Nepal or its engineers. Dix described the disaster as “Mahapralaya”, a term from the Nepali linguistic and Sanskrit philosophical tradition meaning “the great dissolution” a catastrophe so overwhelming that the world as people knew it appears to have been unmade. He said immense flows of water, mud, giant rocks and debris struck multiple hydropower projects at the same time, in terrain that was already among the most difficult and inaccessible on Earth. “In my professional judgment, this event belongs in the same class as the most severe natural disasters of the modern recorded era,” Dix said.
‘Not because of negligence’
Nor does it mean rescuers could simply have concluded that everyone throughout the vast underground system was lost,” he said. “At Chilime, it was as though Mahapralaya itself entered the mountain. “What happened at Chilime was not merely like a bomb detonating at the tunnel entrance. “A bomb has a single point of detonation. At Chilime, an immense flow of water, mud, debris and rocks the size of a bus tore, almost in a single instant, through the entire tunnel system and into the powerhouse. “On the basis of the available evidence, and my direct conversations with the responders at the site, I am firm in my professional conclusion: for those caught in the direct path of the first inrush, there was no possibility of survival. Dix stressed that his assessment did not mean the search should have been abandoned. “That conclusion takes nothing from the search. “Until the tunnels were entered, the evidence examined, and the possible places of survival searched, no one could responsibly abandon the chance that someonw somewhere, might still be alive. Dix also rejected suggestions that the disaster reflected a failure by Nepal or its engineers. Dix praised Nepal’s Army, Police, rescue services, engineers, workers, communities and international rescue teams for continuing the search in extremely difficult conditions.
Because of not only the lives lost, but also the physical violence of the disaster, its simultaneous impact across multiple sites, the destruction of access and communications, and the complexity of the rescue operation, he said this was. Because it travelled through the entire underground system, dix said the force of the flood and debris was unlike a conventional explosion. Because of negligence; not because Nepal failed; not because its engineers were unprepared,” he said, today it lies in ruins — not.
It was more destructive than that,” he said. He said the flow did not simply destroy the tunnel entrance but moved through the underground works, including major plant and control rooms and areas where people worked, ate and rested. Death was instantaneous,” Dix said. He said the rescuers were right to continue.
“Just three weeks earlier, Chilime stood as a proud achievement of Nepali engineering.
India on Saturday continues its humanitarian assistance to flood-hit Nepal, dispatching another 11 tonnes of relief material, including medicines, forensic supplies, tents, hygiene kits and sleeping bags, as the neighbouring country grapples with the aftermath of devastating floods and landslides. The death toll stands at 1,410, including 525 human body remains, according to NDRRMA data released at 7 pm on September 18. NDRRMA said 6,055 people remain missing, while 13,756 people have been rescued.
